You wrote an honest review, warned a neighbor about a contractor, or
posted your side of a dispute, and now a demand letter or a summons says
you defamed someone. The lawsuit is frightening, and it is often meant
to be. The person suing may want to silence you as much as to win.
Before you panic, delete the post, or apologize your way into an
admission, understand two things. Illinois gives a defamation defendant
strong defenses, and in many cases an insurance policy you already pay
for will hire the lawyer who raises them.

This is a plain guide to the defenses that protect someone sued over
a review, a social media post, or a complaint, and to the coverage most
people never think to check.

Continue reading ›

A judgment is a piece of paper that says you were right. It is not money. Illinois will not collect it for you, the clerk will not call the defendant, and nothing about the entry of judgment stops a debtor from doing what many of them started doing the week they were served. The building goes into a spouse’s name. The operating account empties into a new company with a similar name, the same phone number, and the same customers. The equipment sells at a price nobody negotiated to an entity a brother-in-law formed in March. The creditor who spent two years winning finds a defendant who owns a leased car and a phone.

That is the ordinary shape of a collection problem, and it is more solvable than it looks. Illinois gives a judgment creditor the power to compel testimony and documents from the debtor and from anyone holding his property, to freeze that property while the inquiry runs, and to take it. The Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act gives the creditor a way to undo the transfers that emptied the estate in the first place. Neither tool runs by itself, and both reward the creditor who moves early, because the money is usually still traceable in the first ninety days and frequently is not traceable a year later.

Continue reading ›

A former employee, a competitor, or an anonymous account posts
something false about your company, and it spreads before you even see
it. A one-star review claims you cheated a customer you never had. A
rival tells your biggest client that you are about to go under. A
message board names you and calls you a fraud. The statement is not
merely insulting. It costs you the client, the deal, and the reputation
you spent years earning, and the person spreading it is hiding behind a
screen.

Illinois law gives a defamed business or professional real remedies,
and the window to use them is short. You can demand a retraction, force
an anonymous poster into the open, and sue for the harm, and in the
strongest cases the law presumes your damages without making you itemize
every lost dollar. The sooner you act, the more of your reputation you
can protect.

Continue reading ›

You and your partner built the company as equals. Fifty-fifty feltfair at the start. It does not feel fair now. One of you wants to cash out and the other wants to keep building. Or you cannot agree on payroll, on a distribution, on whether to take the loan, and every vote splits two to two. Checks wait for a second signature that never comes. Employees ask who is in charge, and you no longer have a clean answer.

A 50/50 company that stops agreeing can freeze in place. The deadlock feels permanent because neither owner can outvote the other, and the operating agreement you signed years ago never planned for the day the trust ran out. Here is what the paralysis hides. Illinois does not leave feuding owners stuck. The Business Corporation Act, the Limited Liability Company Act, and the partnership statute each hand a judge real power to break the logjam, remove an owner who is abusing the company, and set a fair price on the way out. The owner who understands
those tools negotiates from strength. The owner who does not usually takes the first number the other side offers.

Continue reading ›

The complaint arrives styled as a class action, and the number at the bottom of the page is built to frighten you. A single fee, a single line in a form contract, or a single advertisement, multiplied across every customer you have served for years, until the demand looks large enough to swallow the company. The plaintiff’s lawyer wants you to see that number and reach for the checkbook before anyone asks the harder question. Can this case be a class action at all?

Most consumer fraud class actions are won or lost at class certification, the stage where the court decides whether one named plaintiff may sue on behalf of thousands. Illinois law gives a defendant real tools to defeat certification, and the strongest of them rests on one idea. A consumer fraud claim requires that each plaintiff was actually deceived, and deception rarely reaches thousands of people the same way.

Continue reading ›

By Peter S. Lubin and James V. DiTommaso

You own half of a company you helped build, and the other owner has turned on you. The distributions stopped, but the salary he pays himself did not. You asked to see the books and got silence. Maybe he changed the password on the shared drive, put his brother-in-law on payroll, or started a side venture that looks a great deal like yours. You do not know whether you are about to lose the business, your investment, or both, and every day you wait feels like a day he is using against you.

When owners go to war, the winner is usually the one who moves first and moves correctly. This is a plain guide to what an Illinois commercial litigator actually does to protect an owner in a partner dispute, in the order the work usually happens, so you know what to ask for and what to expect. The law gives you more leverage than the other side wants you to realize.

Continue reading ›

By Peter S. Lubin and James V. DiTommaso

A process server hands your company a class action complaint late on a Friday. By Monday you are reading a theory that turns one disputed
charge or one form document into a claim brought on behalf of thousands of people. The instinct is to wait, to answer the complaint, and to see how bad it gets. That instinct is a mistake. What a defendant does in the first thirty days often decides the case, because the early choices
about where the lawsuit is heard and whether the plaintiff can clear the threshold hurdles shape everything that follows.

This is a plain guide to the opening moves that protect a business sued in a putative class action, from removal to federal court through
the standing defenses that can end the case before a class is ever certified.

Continue reading ›

You and your partner built this together, fifty-fifty, on a handshake and a shared idea of where the company was going. The split worked until it didn’t. Now you disagree about everything that matters, the strategy, the money, whether to sell, and neither of you can outvote the other. Decisions stall. Good employees notice. The company that took years to build is freezing in place while the two of you stare across the table, each certain the other is the problem.

A deadlock feels like a trap because the thing that made the partnership fair, equal ownership, is now the thing that paralyzes it. Illinois does not leave equal owners stranded. The law gives a deadlocked owner a path out, and it is rarely the mutual destruction each side fears. If you are staring at a 50/50 split that has stopped working, the question is not whether you are stuck. It is which exit serves you best.

What does Illinois consider a corporate deadlock?

Your partner started a second company. You learned about it from a customer, not from him, and now you notice that the easy jobs still come to your shared business while the lucrative ones quietly go to his. He says there is nothing wrong with a little outside work. You suspect he has been competing with the company you own together, using its people and its relationships to do it. The question is whether the law sees a betrayal or just ordinary business.

In Illinois, partners and co-owners are not strangers dealing at arm’s length. They stand in a fiduciary relationship, the most demanding standard the law imposes outside a trust, and conduct that would be unremarkable between competitors can be a breach between partners. Knowing where that line sits tells you whether you have a grievance or a case, and it is just as important if you are the partner being accused.

What does an Illinois business partner owe his partners?

You asked a simple question. Where did the money go? You own a piece of the company, the profits that used to reach you have thinned, and you want to see the financials that would explain why. The controlling owner’s answer is a wall. He tells you the records are confidential, or none of your concern, or available only if you drop your objections first. He is betting that you do not know the law gives you a key to that door.

It does. Illinois grants shareholders and LLC members an enforceable right to inspect the books and records of the company they own, and it backs that right with penalties and fee awards when a company refuses without cause. An inspection demand is often the single most useful first move in a partnership or shareholder dispute, because everything else you might claim depends on the facts those records contain.

What records can an Illinois shareholder demand?

Contact Information