The First District Appellate Court of Illinois recently affirmed the entry of summary judgment against the plaintiff in a commercial breach of contract and mechanic’s lien dispute. In upholding the grant of summary judgment, the Court found that the plaintiff’s discovery responses doomed its mechanic’s lien claim, providing yet another…
Articles Posted in Business Disputes
Insurance Company not Prevented From Later Denying Payment for Claim it Initially Defended
An insurance company defended a construction firm against a claim by a condo association for defective design and construction of a building, as it thought the claim arose during the company’s policy period. The insurance company was not estopped from later denying payment for the claim when it was discovered…
Appeals Court Awards Damages to Subcontractor, Denying Set-Off For General Contractor
An electrical subcontractor sued the general contractor after the general contractor withheld $58,000. The general contractor claimed that it was owed a setoff for work performed by other electricians, but the trial court found that the money spent by the general contractor was not within the scope of the original…
The Litigation Environment Gets Hot When Corporations Get Sued For Climate Change
Worldwide, the impact of global change is being felt. While some people deny that climate change is even happening, the courts are, in fact, seeing the effects in the litigation scene. Suits concerning the issue are trending upwards. Jurisdictional restraints and distance are not stopping litigants from coming forward to…
Lubin Austermuehle Co-Counsel and Colleague Dmitry Feofanov Argues Important UCC Issue in Illinois Supreme Court Regarding Revoking Acceptance of a Defective RV With a Leaky Roof
Our longtime co-counsel and colleague Dmitry Feofanov argued an important case this week before the Illinois Supreme Court concerning a consumer’s ability to revoke acceptance of a brand new RV with a hidden defect — a leaky roof. The consumers revoked acceptance after the RV dealer couldn’t provide an estimated…
ARC Welding v. American Welding — Appellate Court Finds Taking Monies from Reserve Would Constitute a Windfall — Chicago Business Litigation Lawyers near Oak Brook and Naperville
Where an asset purchase agreement between two companies did not contemplate the forfeiture of an entire reserve payment as a result of an audit of assets taking one month longer than originally contemplated, and such a forfeiture would result in a windfall for one of the parties. ARC Welding Supply…
A-1 Packaging v. Firefly RFID Solutions Court Allows Some Breach of Contract Claims to Proceed for Misrepresenting Capacity to Complete Construction Project and Dismisses Some Claims Against Officers and Directors — Best Chicago Business Dispute Lawyers
When officers of a corporation misrepresented the capacity of the corporation to meet requirements of an RFID manufacturing project, the district court allowed some claims for breach of contract, quantum meruit, and unjust enrichment to proceed. The court also dismissed some claims against the individual officers of the corporation, based…
Designer Direct v. PNC Financial Services Court Grants Summary Judgment on Breach of Contract Claim Under UCC Provisions — Chicago Business Dispute Lawyers Near Oak Brook
The district court granted summary judgment to a bank on a breach of contract claim where a bank customer was precluded from suing bank for payment of fraudulent checks because customer did not report fraud within 90 days of receiving statement containing copy of first fraudulent check, and account agreement…
Trinity v. ColFin Affirms That a Mistake is Not Binding if it is not Relied Upon — Chicago and Oak Brook Real-Estate Litigation Attorneys
Where the mortgage on a development company’s property was mistakenly recorded as satisfied, and then later corrected, the mistaken release did not extinguish the debt, and the contract was still effective. Trinity 83 Development borrowed $2 million from a bank in return for a mortgage on real property and a…
MEP Construction v. Truco MP LLC Summary Judgment in Mechanics Lien Case Affirmed — Top DuPage County Breach of Contract Lawyers Near Wheaton and Naperville
Where a construction manager overstated amount in mechanic’s lien by more than 100%, and overstatement consisted of work performed by other contractors that manager did not have a contractual relationship with, the circuit court did not err in granting summary judgment to restaurant owner alleging constructive fraud on part of…